CloakView vs Smog AI

The closest pair on this site: both are native Mac overlays that stay invisible to a screen share.

Figures from smog-ai.com/pricing · November 2026

Smog and CloakView are the nearest neighbours here. Both are native Mac overlays that hide from screen sharing, both keep transcripts on your machine, and both can run on your own OpenAI key instead of a bundled subscription. The differences are in the price shape and the ceilings.

Smog's plans, from its own pricing page in November 2026: a free tier with the undetectable overlay and a limited token quota, Pro at $24.99/month (less on annual billing) with their models included, and a $199 one-time Lifetime licence, listed at $299 and capped at 50 seats, which lets you bring your own OpenAI key. CloakView has no quota and no account at all.

Diagram: the window on the left, shared with the call, stays clean; the CloakView overlay on the right sits on your own screen.
The overlay is drawn on your Mac only, so it never lands in the window you share.

Side by side

Cost to startCloakViewFree app. No account, no card.Smog AIFree tier, with the undetectable overlay included and a limited token quota.
Ongoing costCloakViewNo subscription. You pay OpenAI for your own usage. CloakView Pro is a single $99 payment.Smog AIPro at $24.99/month, or a $199 one-time Lifetime licence (listed at $299, 50 seats).
Hiding the overlay from a screen shareCloakViewIncluded in every tier, free app included.Smog AIIncluded from the free tier up. Their strongest point, and it is a fair one.
Your own API keyCloakViewYes, for every feature. That is the only way it works.Smog AIOn the Lifetime plan. Pro bundles access to their models instead.
Usage quotaCloakViewNone. Your only ceiling is the spending limit you set in your own OpenAI account.Smog AIThe free tier is metered by a token quota; paid tiers are unlimited under a fair-use policy.
Where your data goesCloakViewAudio and transcripts on your Mac. No CloakView backend, no telemetry.Smog AIInterface, transcripts and notes stored locally; AI requests send the minimum text needed, which they say is not stored.
PlatformsCloakViewmacOS 14.2 or later, Apple Silicon.Smog AImacOS 14.2 or later (Apple Silicon; Intel if the Mac runs 14.2), plus a Windows 10/11 x64 beta.
LanguagesCloakViewOpenAI realtime transcription; live translation on Pro.Smog AIAutomatic language detection and real-time translation.
Reading your screenCloakViewPro reads a question or task straight off your screen.Smog AIVision — screen analysis, capped by the token quota on the free tier.
Notes and exportCloakViewAutomatic and manual notes; searchable history on Pro.Smog AIAutomatic and manual notes, with PDF, Markdown and email export on paid tiers.
Best fitCloakViewMac-only users who want one payment, no account and their own key from the first launch.Smog AIPeople who want a Windows beta or a lifetime licence that includes the models.

Where Smog AI is the better choice

  • A lifetime plan with models included

    Smog's $199 Lifetime licence is one payment for the app and the AI behind it. If you would rather never open an OpenAI dashboard, that is a coherent offer — CloakView always needs a key.

  • Windows, in beta

    Smog runs a Windows 10/11 x64 beta. CloakView is macOS on Apple Silicon only, so if your work laptop is a PC, this comparison ends there.

  • More export formats

    PDF, Markdown and email export on the paid tiers are documented on their pricing page. CloakView's history is searchable but the export surface is narrower.

Where CloakView is the better choice

  • Half the price of the lifetime licence

    Pro is $99 once, against $199 for Smog's lifetime plan — and you keep the key, so the model and the per-token cost stay yours.

  • No token quota anywhere

    The free CloakView app has no metered tier and no fair-use throttle. The only limit is your own OpenAI spending limit, which you set and can change.

  • No account, no sign-in

    There is no CloakView account to create, verify or lose. Paste the key and the app works; revoke the key and it stops.

  • Nothing to unlearn for macOS users

    One DMG, Apple Silicon only, no Intel fallback to reason about — the same machine that runs your interview runs the app at native speed.

Looking for a Smog AI alternative?

Smog AI is the closest product to CloakView: a native Mac overlay that disappears from a screen share and keeps transcripts on the machine. People look for an alternative for two reasons — the price shape and the ceiling. Smog's paid plans are a subscription or a $199 lifetime licence, and its free tier is metered by a token quota.

CloakView answers both directly: Pro is $99 once, and there is no quota at all; the only limit is the spending limit you set inside your own OpenAI account. What Smog still does and CloakView does not: a Windows 10/11 beta, and export to PDF, Markdown and email.

Is there a Smog AI alternative without a token quota?

CloakView has no metered tier and no fair-use throttle; the only ceiling is the spending limit you set in your own OpenAI account. Smog's free tier is metered by tokens, with unlimited use on its paid plans.

Is there a cheaper alternative to Smog AI's lifetime licence?

CloakView Pro is $99 once, against $199 for Smog's lifetime plan, and in both cases you keep your own OpenAI key and pay OpenAI for usage. Smog's lifetime licence includes its models on the Pro subscription instead; the two price shapes are compared above.

Which one to buy

These two are genuinely close, so buy on the detail that matters to you. Smog wins if you need Windows, want the models included in one lifetime payment, or export a lot. CloakView wins if you want the cheapest one-time price, no quota and no account, and you are happy to own the OpenAI key yourself.

Common questions

Is Smog cheaper than CloakView?

It depends on the shape you buy. Both have free tiers with the stealth overlay. Beyond that, Smog sells $24.99/month with models included or a $199 lifetime licence; CloakView gives you the app free and Pro for a one-time $99, with OpenAI billing your usage separately.

Does CloakView have a token quota?

No. There is no metered tier and no fair-use throttle in the app; the only limit is the spending limit you set inside your OpenAI account.

Which one runs on Windows?

Smog has a Windows 10/11 x64 beta. CloakView is macOS 14.2+ on Apple Silicon only, with no Windows build.

Can I bring my own key to both?

Yes, but on different plans. Smog offers it on the Lifetime licence, while Pro bundles their models. CloakView only works with your own OpenAI key, in every tier.

Try it before you decide

The app is free and needs no account. Download it, paste an OpenAI key, and run it on your next call — the overlay stays out of screen shares from the first launch.

Download for macOS

macOS 14.2 or later · Apple Silicon · signed and notarized

Other comparisons